By ERIC GRIFFITH /
Very few shows have caused me to actively mourn their passing. Most
outlive their welcome ("Picket Fences," "Roseanne"), while others
die at just the right time ("Seinfeld," "The Larry Sanders Show,"
even "Homicide").
This past season saw the final episode of the syndicated "Star
Trek: Deep Space Nine," and I continue to brood, knowing that the
only place left to boldly go where no one has gone before is on
UPN's "Star Trek: Voyager" (Wednesdays at 9 p.m.).
Unfortunately, I’m not convinced the series can handle the job.
"Voyager" has long been hampered by its "Lost in Space"
shtick, as the crew of the Federation ship tries to return home
after being bounced a quadrant away by an omnipotent being.
Returning home is the main hook the show has – and it no longer
works.
"Voyager’s" characters have traits or concerns that carry over
from episode to episode, but the only cohesive factor throughout is
the crew asking, "Are we there yet?"
It's also unfortunate that touring the Delta Quadrant has led to
little more than monster/battle-of-the-week scenarios. If "Xena:
Warrior Princess" can sustain continuing plots during the course of
several self-contained episodes, I'll hold UPN's only success to the
same standard.
"Voyager's" fifth season opener, "Equinox
Part II," was a continuation of the cliffhanger involving Captain
Janeway’s (Kate Mulgrew) pursuit of the USS Equinox's Captain Ransom
(guest John Savage), who had been murdering aliens in an effort to
get home faster. Equinox, like Voyager, was transported thousands of
light years from home. The second episode of the season involved
Seven of Nine (Jeri Ryan) meeting former Borg drone buddies. Space
is an awfully small place.
The opener contained the single
vilest scene I’ve ever witnessed from a supposedly heroic character
(who wasn’t possessed or brainwashed). Janeway, infuriated by her
inability to capture Captain Ransom, captures one of his crewmen and
attempts to extort information from him by handing him over to a
homicidal alien. Only Chakotay (Robert Beltran), Janeway's first
officer, saves the man as she crosses the line. The fact that she
acknowledges her error in judgment later doesn’t diminish the
disturbing nature of this event. She still gets to run the ship. The
course of the series has often brought Janeway’s actions into
question; this episode should be the nail in her coffin if they do
return home to face court martial.
Along with its
similarities to "Lost in Space," "Voyager" also draws on the
original '60s "Trek," with Janeway as Kirk, Tuvok (Tim Russ) or
Chokotay taking turns as Spock and several red shirts. The
subordinates simply get more lines, or tighter outfits, as is the
case with the show’s most popular character, Seven of Nine. Her
wooden performance makes one ache for the subtle albeit dry humor
Brent Spiner brought to the character of Data in "The Next
Generation." "Voyager’s" saving grace continues to be Robert
Picardo’s performance as the holographic, yet perfectly egotistical,
Doctor.
"Voyager" tries hard to be what it should –
action-packed with great stories and good performances – but seldom
hits on all cylinders. There’s no faulting the cast; they recite
their techno-jargon lines with just the right amount of seriousness.
The idea factory at Paramount continues to do some unique things,
but how many times are we going to see the Voyager virtually
destroyed and then running like new a week later?
For
Trekkies, it’s impossible to look at "Star Trek" outside of the
far-reaching tapestry of stories since the '60s: many bad and a few
so perfect they make up for the rest with aplomb. The joy of "DS9"
was in watching the unfolding events within and without the
characters' lives — the war, the weddings, the political intrigue,
the religious leaders who were plotting, and the oppressors who
became sympathetic. "Voyager’s" place in that grandiose world is
peripheral. Bring them home, Paramount. Bring them home.